حلقات النقاش باللغة العربيةبعض الكتب لا يقرأها الا كاتبها وبعض اصدقاءه - هل نريدها؟؟؟!!

User avatar
becareman
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 180
Joined: 19 May 2010, 18:41
University: Omdurman Islamic University
Country & City: Omdurman
Degree (College): MBBS
Graduation Year: 1955
Plan \ Working On: ----
Working on (2): ----
Speciality: Anesthesia & ICU
Job Title: Specialist
Work Place: KSA
Has thanked: 5 times
Been thanked: 19 times
Contact:

بعض الكتب لا يقرأها الا كاتبها وبعض اصدقاءه - هل نريدها؟؟؟!!

Unread post by becareman » 22 Nov 2012, 23:00

بعض الكتب لا يقرأها الا كاتبها وبعض اصدقاءه - هل نريدها
اعزائي الاحباب بعض الكتب يشدنا عنوانها فنعتقد انها بحر من العلوم
ولكن في الحقيقة انها تفتقر لادنى مقومات المرجع العلمي
ما لفت انتباهي اليوم وانا في رحلة بحثي عن بعض الكتب الجديدة في النت وجدت كتابا في الباثوفسيولوجي شدني
اضعت وقتا في تنزيل الكتاب
وكنت على وشك رفعه هنا لكن واثناء بحثي عن صورة الغلاف وجدت بعض التعليقات عن الكتاب
في احد المواقع . فاذهلني ما وصف به الكتاب من ضعف ومن البعض الذين يشيرون الى انهم يعرفون المؤلف نفسه
فقررت ان اقترح عليكم محاولة تقييم الكتب غير المعروفة والجديدة قبل رفعها
لان ضياع زمن فرد منا خير من ضياع ازمنة الجميع
ودمتم لي طيبون

اترككم الان مع بعض التعليقات على ذاك الكتاب
PAPERBACK:
This book has too little information for a med student, even in first or second year. A few areas are relatively well covered, but it's neither basic enough to be used as a learning tool nor detailed enough to be used as a reference. I use it once in a while, but only in conjuction with Harrison's, UptoDate, and other such references. You'll still need to go back to a Pathololgy and a Physiology text to find what you're looking for.
LONE RANGER:
It is hard to locate topics and information in this format. I would pay extra for an easier content locator. The content is complete and informational though. Its an okay purchase.
JMTG:
This book is the benchmark of bad textbooks. I refuse to believe the text ever saw an editor before it went into print; the authors - especially McPhee himself - wouldn't be able to recognize DIDACTICS if it came flying into his face; the text is extremely convulted written, confusing, unstructured, concepts are never connected, void of clarity, and in many instances just straight out wrong or self-contradictory; the book has no intention of actually conveying knowledge, instead it keeps digging into itself.

Also, do not believe the other reviewers who give this book 5 stars, they are not actual persons, but agencies paid by the publishers. Or, as I cannot actually attest to that, suffice to say anyone taking medical didactics seriously simply cannot reward this book 5 stars.

WHAT was that book ???
images (21).jpg
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Image
لكل شيءٍ إذا ما تم نقصانُ **فلا يُغرُّ بطيب العيش إنسانُ
هي الأيامُ كما شاهدتها دُولٌ**مَن سَرَّهُ زَمنٌ ساءَتهُ أزمانُ
**
ألا كل ما خلا الـلـه بـاطـل**وكل نعـيم لا مـحـالة زائل
**
**
وكل امرىء يوماً سيعرف سعيه**إذا حصلت عند الإله الحصائل
نسأل الله التوفيق للجميع في الدارين
[/align]

mohammad karrar
Member
Member
Posts: 18
Joined: 27 Jun 2013, 21:42
University: Qadarif University
Country & City: Qadarif
Degree (College): MBBS
Graduation Year: 2015
Plan \ Working On: Finishing Medical School
Speciality: No Plans Yet
Job Title: Medical Student
Work Place: Qadarif university
Has thanked: 4 times
Contact:

Re: بعض الكتب لا يقرأها الا كاتبها وبعض اصدقاءه - هل نريدها؟

Unread post by mohammad karrar » 01 Sep 2014, 14:40

i have read the 7th edition .. seem to be rewritten or revised .. those are considered doctors from well-known universities .. but the nature of the book could be mimic .. being not a textbook of pathphysiology but just an introduction to clinical medicine by emphasizing the mechanisms behind some important signs and symptoms .. it is pointed for undergraduate student from a respected series (LANGE) .. really it helped me as i use it as what written for .. i am still searching for a reliable pathophysiology text :) most of them are very poor in informations :(

Post Reply

Return to “حلقات النقاش باللغة العربية”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests